Tuesday, September 22, 2009

No Class- Feminist Response

Let me just start out by saying that I was a bit confused about this assignment, but I am sure it is my fault. I felt the criticism was a bit odd because a woman did not talk, it was only by a woman through a man. Even though I knew that Mary Shelley did not put her name on the book, it was a light bulb moment for me because of the female criticism at that time and I found it interesting. But now that it is all straightened out, let me tell you about my view of the "oppressive domesticity" of Victor's family. I believe that Victor's family was oppressive because it too perfect; it contradicted society. No one is that perfect. Her father and mother were figures that isolated Victor from the outside world. His mother was the perfect little homemaker and the father was a gentleman. But we all know nothing is perfect (except the divine power of God, of course). Human nature is evil and sinful, so there must have been something wrong with the picture. Women were seen stereotypically as the ones who stayed home and took care of the household while the other men traveled and were disciplinary. Victor was used to being the center of attention and taken care of and even played with others such as Elizabeth. It was not until deaths in the family did Victor experience real freedom. When he did, he took his freedom to the extreme by creating a new being. He then took the being for granted and rejected him because the monster was not perfect like his family had been. I believe this corresponds with Shelley because like Victor, she was oppressed as well until later in life when women's writing was more accepted. The lightbulb moments were really happening this morning and that my friends is the exciting part!!!

5 comments:

  1. Can I just say I love your post! I could really tell that the lightbulb did indeed come on! I completely agree with you that it was devastating that Shelley could not put her own name on her work originally.

    I love how you put that Victor's family "contradicted society." Yes indeed, no human being is perfect. Especially when you put a group of human beings together, that group is destined to have major flaws and issues. I believe that because Victor perceived his family as "perfect" is where all the issues started, first with his mother's death and then the creation of the creature followed by the deaths of the rest of his family.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I loved your post as well, I wished I could have put a picture of a lightbulb coming on, but it didn't allow me to.

    But anyways, I can understand how once deaths took place in Victor's family that he could finally experience freedom. Mainly because when everyone around is doing everything perfect, it makes as if imperfection and mistakes are never allowed and if mistakes are made, you are felt like you are no longer apart of the family. So because of the high expectations he had growing up, when he created his own creature, he created something completely the opposite of what was drilled into him.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Kathryn- I wonder what would have happened if Victor DID realize that his family was too perfect? Would he have reaked havoc on the poor monster? The monster was only the way he was because that is what he was taught, rejection. He killed others because he had already tried loving them. Thanks for the compliment! :)

    ReplyDelete
  4. Tesia! The lightbulb pic would have been perfect; you are so creative! The same questions are posed to you( because I know how much you love questions). What do you think would be different? Personally, I think that obviously he would have loved the monster and made a mate for the monster.How weird. What if he started like a whole family? Well, we will never know. What are your thoughts?

    ReplyDelete
  5. I wonder though if he had made him a mate, would Victor have had to make a whole family? Because if two people get together, that have the appropriate parts, I would think they could figure out the rest on their own. Just as with Adam and Eve, God made them both out of the dirt, and then they birthed the rest of the world.

    ReplyDelete